If you’re in the market for Chelsea-style safety boots, the Timberland PRO Nashoba and the MooseLog 5666 are two standout choices. Both are built with full-grain waterproof leather, meet CSA Z195 and ASTM F2413 certifications, and feature lightweight composite toes with ESR protection. From a construction standpoint, they are remarkably similar — but there’s one core difference that sets them apart.
Let’s take a closer look.
1. Certifications
MooseLog 5666: CSA Z195 & ASTM F2413 certified
Timberland Nashoba: CSA Z195 & ASTM F2413 certified
No confusion here. Both are certified for Canadian and U.S. safety standards, making them valid choices on any regulated job site.
2. Toe Protection
MooseLog 5666: Composite Toe (metal-free, impact and compression rated)
Timberland Nashoba: Composite Toe (metal-free, impact and compression rated)
These boots offer the same protective benefits, shielding your toes from workplace hazards without adding the weight of steel.
3. Outsole Construction & Performance
MooseLog 5666: Built with our proprietary SafeTread® rubber outsole system. It offers certified slip, oil, and cut resistance and is heat resistant up to 300°C. The sole is attached using direct-injected PU construction for long-term flexibility and reduced risk of sole separation.
Timberland Nashoba: Features a TPU outsole with slip and oil resistance. The sole is cemented, which is common for many boots but may not offer the same heat resistance or flexibility as direct-injected methods.
This is where the biggest difference lies. If your work environment includes hot surfaces or you want maximum durability from the sole itself, MooseLog takes the lead.
Want to learn more about outsole types and how cemented soles compare to direct-injected PU? Check out this detailed blog for a full breakdown.
4. Comfort & Support
MooseLog 5666: Designed for long shifts. Includes our Single-density PU footbed insole and a wider toe box for added comfort over time. Lightweight feel with a flexible step.
Timberland Nashoba: Comes with Timberland’s anti-fatigue insole technology. Supportive and suitable for extended wear.
Both brands prioritize comfort, but MooseLog focuses more on cushioning and mobility, while Timberland sticks with its tried-and-true formula.
5. Materials & Durability
MooseLog 5666: Premium full-grain leather that’s LWG-certified. Abrasion-resistant toe cap, sealed stitching, and a moisture-wicking lining.
Timberland Nashoba: High-quality full-grain leather with a rubber toe bumper and traditional waterproofing treatment.
Material-wise, these boots are nearly identical. Both are durable, weather-ready, and built for jobsite abuse.
6. Price Comparison
MooseLog 5666: $150 CAD
Timberland Nashoba: $230 CAD
That’s an $80 difference — and given how closely matched these boots are in terms of specs and certifications, it’s worth asking why. The answer comes down to branding.
Timberland is a well-known global name with a legacy in workwear. But if you care about performance and construction over reputation, MooseLog delivers the same protection and comfort, with added outsole benefits, at a more accessible price.
Final Thoughts
Both the Timberland Nashoba and MooseLog 5666 stand out as reliable, stylish safety boots for pros who want Chelsea simplicity with full protective performance. If you’re loyal to Timberland and want a familiar name, you won’t be disappointed. But if you’re looking for objective value, MooseLog makes a strong case.
You get certified protection, rugged leather, a more advanced outsole, and serious comfort for $80 less.
Looking for more in-depth boot comparisons? We're working on one-to-one brand matchups and will update this page with links as they go live. If you’re looking for a broader comparison across multiple Chelsea safety boots, check out this roundup blog for a full breakdown of top brands.
